Here is the Pacer record for the action:

PACER session date: Tuesday July 14, 1998 07:37:22 PM EDT 
Case docket was last updated on: 06/03/98.


Docket as of June 23, 1998 7:13 am               Page 1   

Proceedings include all events.
2:98cv103     Lyons Partnership v. Creegan Company Inc, et al            REFER
                                                                         JURY
                                                            REFER  JURY
                       U.S. District Court
          for the Southern District of Ohio (Columbus)

               CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 98-CV-103

Lyons Partnership v. Creegan Company Inc, et al             Filed: 01/23/98
Assigned to: Judge Edmund A Sargus, Jr       Jury demand: Defendant
             Referred to: Mag. Judge Mark R. Abel
Demand: $0,000                               Nature of Suit:  840
Lead Docket: None                            Jurisdiction: Federal Question
Dkt# in other court: None

Cause: 15:1114 Trademark Infringement


LYONS PARTNERSHIP L P             Richard J DiSantis
     plaintiff                    [COR LD NTC]
                                  Buckley King & Bluso
                                  1400 Bank One Center
                                  Cleveland, OH 44114
                                  216-363-1400


   v.


CREEGAN COMPANY INC               James Craig Carpenter
aka                               [COR LD NTC]
Creegan's Christmas Corner        Lane Alton & Horst - 2
     defendant                    175 S Third Street
                                  Columbus, OH 43215-5100
                                  614-228-6885
                                  FTS 228-0146


GEORGE CREEGAN                    James Craig Carpenter
     defendant                    (See above)
                                  [COR LD NTC]


JOANN CREEGAN                     James Craig Carpenter
     defendant                    (See above)
                                  [COR LD NTC]


A MAD HATTER COSTUME SHOP         Michael M Heimlich
     defendant                    (614) 436-0539
                                  [COR LD NTC]
                                  Baran Piper Tarkowsky
                                  Fitzgerald & Theis - 2
                                  6877 N High Street
                                  Suite 105



Docket as of June 23, 1998 7:13 am               Page 2   

Proceedings include all events.
2:98cv103     Lyons Partnership v. Creegan Company Inc, et al            REFER
                                                                         JURY
                                  Worthington, OH 43085
                                  614-436-0539


MAD HATTER COSTUMES
     defendant
 [term  01/23/98]


LEMKE GROUP INC
dba
A Mad Hatter Costume Shop
dba
Mad Hatter Costumes
     defendant
 [term  03/27/98]


GREATER DAYTON FILM COMMIS,
The
dba
A Mad Hatter Costume Shop
dba
Mad Hatter Costumes
     defendant


BETTY L LEMKE, Individually
and/or dba A Mad Hatter
Costume Shop and/or Mad Hatter
Costumes
     defendant
 [term  03/27/98]


BETTY D LEMKE, Individually       Michael M Heimlich
and/or dba A Mad Hatter           (See above)
Costume Shop and/or Mad Hatter    [COR LD NTC]
Costumes
dba
A Mad Hatter Costume Shop
     defendant


COSTUME CASTLE                    Alexander M Andrews
     defendant                    [COR LD NTC]
                                  Ulmer & Berne - 2
                                  88 E Broad Street
                                  Suite 1980
                                  Columbus, OH 43215-3506
                                  (614) 228-8400
                                  FTS 228-8561





Docket as of June 23, 1998 7:13 am               Page 3   

Proceedings include all events.
2:98cv103     Lyons Partnership v. Creegan Company Inc, et al            REFER
                                                                         JURY
ALICE ANDOLINA, Individually      Alexander M Andrews
and                               (See above)
dba                               [COR LD NTC]
Costume Castle
     defendant


RICHARD ANDOLINA, Individually    Alexander M Andrews
and                               (See above)
dba                               [COR LD NTC]
Costume Castle
     defendant


COSTUME KING                      Michael M Heimlich
     defendant                    (See above)
                                  [COR LD NTC]


CATHERINE KING, Owner of          Michael M Heimlich
Costume King                      (See above)
     defendant                    [COR LD NTC]


FOY'S VARIETY STORE               Luis Manuel Alcalde
dba                               614-228-5511
Foy's Halloween Store             PO 15039
dba                               [COR LD NTC]
Foy's Costume Store               Crabbe Brown Jones Potts &
dba                               Schmidt - 2
Foy's Kids Costume Store          500 S Front Street
dba                               Suite 1200
Foy's Haunted House Store         Columbus, OH 43215
     defendant                    614-228-5511
                                  FTS 229-4559


MICHAEL FOY, individually and     Luis Manuel Alcalde
dba Foy's Vairety Store, Foy's    (See above)
Halloween Store, Foy's Costume    [COR LD NTC]
Store, Foy's Kids Costume
Store, and/or Foy's Haunted
House Store
     defendant


PARTY FANTASY                     Michael M Heimlich
     defendant                    (See above)
                                  [COR LD NTC]


KATHY SHANKLIN, Individually      Michael M Heimlich
and/or                            (See above)
dba                               [COR LD NTC]



Docket as of June 23, 1998 7:13 am               Page 4   

Proceedings include all events.
2:98cv103     Lyons Partnership v. Creegan Company Inc, et al            REFER
                                                                         JURY
Party Fantasy
     defendant


JOHN SHANKLIN, Individually       Michael M Heimlich
and/or                            (See above)
dba                               [COR LD NTC]
Party Fantasy
     defendant


PENROD ENTERPRISES                Alexander M Andrews
dba                               (See above)
Brides House of Luxury            [COR LD NTC]
dba
Costumes By Penrod
     defendant


SUZANNE PHELPS, Individually      Alexander M Andrews
and/or                            (See above)
     defendant                    [COR LD NTC]


EVELYN MUNCIE                     Alexander M Andrews
dba                               (See above)
Penrod Enterprises                [COR LD NTC]
dba
Brides House of Luxury
dba
Costumes By Penrod
     defendant




Docket as of June 23, 1998 7:13 am               Page 5   

Proceedings include all events.
2:98cv103     Lyons Partnership v. Creegan Company Inc, et al            REFER
                                                                         JURY
1/23/98  1       COMPLAINT  (referred to Mag. Judge Mark R. Abel )  ( no.
                 pgs: 40 + exhibits) (mc) [Entry date 01/26/98]

3/9/98   2       ATTORNEY APPEARANCE for defendant Costume King, defendant
                 Catherine King  by Michael M Heimlich ( no pgs: 4) (mc)
                 [Entry date 03/10/98]

3/9/98   --      Summons issued as to dfts A Mad Hatter Costume, Lemke Group
                 Inc, Greater Dayton Film, Betty L Lemke, Betty D Lemke,
                 Costume Castle, Alice Andolina, Richard Andolina, Foy's
                 Variety Store, Michael Foy, Kathy Shanklin, John Shanklin,
                 Evelyn Muncie (mc) [Entry date 03/10/98]

3/17/98  4       MOTION by plaintiff Lyons Partnership to stay proceedings
                 pending a ruling on motion to transfer and consolidate (
                 no pgs: 18 + exhibits) (mc) [Entry date 03/18/98]

3/17/98  --      Summons issued as to dfts Party Fantasy, Kathy Shanklin (mc)
                 [Entry date 03/18/98]

3/17/98  3       NOTICE by plaintiff Lyons Partnership of filing motion to
                 transfer case to Northern Disitrict of Texas or the
                 Southern District of CA and motion to consolidate cases,
                 which are being filed with the Judicial Panel on
                 Multidistrict Litigation ( no pgs: 1 + attchments) (mc)
                 [Entry date 05/11/98]

3/18/98  5       ATTORNEY APPEARANCE for Creegan Company Inc, George
                 Creegan, Joann Creegan  by James Craig Carpenter ( no pgs:
                 3) (mc)

3/23/98  6       SEPARATE ANSWER by defendant Catherine King, defendant
                 Costume King no pgs: 7) (mc) [Entry date 03/24/98]

3/24/98  7       RETURN OF SERVICE executed upon defendant Party Fantasy,
                 defendant Kathy Shanklin, defendant John Shanklin  on
                 3/23/98 ( no pgs: 6) (mc)

3/24/98  8       RETURN OF SERVICE executed upon defendant Foy's Variety
                 Store, defendant Michael Foy  on 3/20/98 ( no pgs: 10) (mc)

3/24/98  9       RETURN OF SERVICE executed upon defendant A Mad Hatter
                 Costume, defendant Lemke Group Inc, defendant Greater
                 Dayton Film, defendant Betty D Lemke  on 3/20/98 ( no pgs:
                 8) (mc)

3/24/98  10      RETURN OF SERVICE executed upon defendant Betty L Lemke,
                 defendant Costume Castle, defendant Alice Andolina,
                 defendant Richard Andolina, defendant Penrod Enterprises,
                 defendant Evelyn Muncie  on 3/23/98 ( no pgs: 6) (mc)

3/26/98  11      ANSWER by defendant Creegan Company Inc aka Creegan's
                 Christmas Corner; jury demand ( no pgs: 8) (mc)
                 [Entry date 03/27/98]



Docket as of June 23, 1998 7:13 am               Page 6   

Proceedings include all events.
2:98cv103     Lyons Partnership v. Creegan Company Inc, et al            REFER
                                                                         JURY

3/26/98  12      ANSWER by defendant Joann Creegan, defendant George Creegan;
                  jury demand ( no pgs: 8) (mc) [Entry date 03/27/98]

3/27/98  13      ATTORNEY APPEARANCE for defendants Costume Castle,  Alice
                 Andolina, Richard Andolina  by Alexander M Andrews ( no
                 pgs: 2) (mc)

3/27/98  14      NOTICE of Dismissal as to party Lemke Group Inc, party
                 Betty L Lemke ( no pgs.: 2) (mc)

4/9/98   15      ANSWER by defendant Michael Foy, defendant Foy's Variety
                 Store; jury demand ( no pgs: 9) (mc)

4/9/98   16      ATTORNEY APPEARANCE for defendant Suzanne Phelps, defendant
                 Penrod Enterprises  by Alexander M Andrews ( no pgs: 2) (mc)
                 [Entry date 04/10/98]

4/10/98  17      SEPARATE ANSWER by defendant Party Fantasy, defendant Kathy
                 Shanklin, defendant John Shanklin ( no pgs: 7) (mc)
                 [Entry date 04/13/98]

4/14/98  18      ANSWER by defendant Alice Andolina, defendant Richard
                 Andolina, defendant Costume Castle; jury demand ( no pgs:
                 15) (mc)

4/21/98  19      AMENDED ANSWER [15-1] by defendant Michael Foy, defendant
                 Foy's Variety Store; jury demand ( no pgs: 8) (mc)

4/28/98  20      SEPARATE ANSWER by defendant Penrod Enterprises, defendant
                 Evelyn Muncie; jury demand ( no pgs: 15) (mc)
                 [Edit date 04/28/98]

5/1/98   21      ORDER  by Mag. Judge Mark R. Abel  granting  motion to stay
                 proceedings pending a ruling on motion to transfer and
                 consolidate [4-1] ; Joint Written Status report ddl set
                 for 7/29/98 with MRA (cc:  all counsel) ( no pgs: 2) (sm)

5/8/98   22      NOTICE of filing with the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict
                 Litigation - dfts Michael Foy's and Foy's Variety Store
                 memorandum contra pltf's motion for transfer and
                 consolidation ( no pgs: 3 + attachments) (mc)
                 [Entry date 05/11/98]

5/20/98  23      ATTORNEY APPEARANCE for defendant Betty D Lemke, defendant
                 A Mad Hatter Costume  by Michael M Heimlich ( no pgs: 3) (mc)
                 [Entry date 05/21/98]

5/20/98  24      SEPARATE ANSWER by defendant Betty D Lemke, defendant A Mad
                 Hatter Costume ( no pgs: 6) (mc) [Entry date 05/22/98]




Docket as of June 23, 1998 7:13 am               Page 7   

Proceedings include all events.
2:98cv103     Lyons Partnership v. Creegan Company Inc, et al            REFER
                                                                         JURY
5/27/98  25      NOTICE by defendant Foy's Variety Store, defendant Michael
                 Foy of filing, with the MDL Panel, Amended Memorandum
                 Contra pltf's Motion for Transfer and Consolidation ( no
                 pgs: 3 + attachment) (mc)

6/3/98   26      NOTICE of filing memo contra to pltf's motion for transfer
                 and consolidation (filed with MDL panel) by defendant
                 Creegan Company Inc, defendant George Creegan, defendant
                 Joann Creegan  ( no pgs: 3) (sm)

[END OF DOCKET: 2:98cv103]

There can be no assurance that the Pacer report posted in this web page is up to date. Keep in mind that if you want current Pacer information on this case, you should do your own Pacer search. The modem number for the Pacer computer for this Court is 1-888-297-9938; you need a Pacer user ID and password to do Pacer searches.

Return to the main Ference & Associates Barney Litigation page.

Last revised July 14, 1998.


This page is http://www.ferencelaw.com/barney/ohsd.sht